View or edit on GitHub
This page is synchronized from trase/data/brazil/soy/indicators/out/q3_2026/qa/comparing_to_previous_results.md. Last modified on 2026-11-02 10:41 CET by dependabot[bot].
Please view or edit the original file there; changes should be reflected here after a midnight build (CET time),
or manually triggering it with a GitHub action (link).
QA Comparison: New vs. Legacy Soy Deforestation & Emissions Indicators
Florian Gollnow 2026-08-30
Setup & Libraries
── Attaching core tidyverse packages ──────────────────────── tidyverse 2.0.0 ──
✔ dplyr 1.2.1 ✔ readr 2.2.0
✔ forcats 1.0.1 ✔ stringr 1.6.0
✔ ggplot2 4.0.3 ✔ tibble 3.3.1
✔ lubridate 1.9.5 ✔ tidyr 1.3.2
✔ purrr 1.2.2
── Conflicts ────────────────────────────────────────── tidyverse_conflicts() ──
✖ dplyr::filter() masks stats::filter()
✖ dplyr::lag() masks stats::lag()
ℹ Use the conflicted package (<http://conflicted.r-lib.org/>) to force all conflicts to become errors
Attaching package: 'arrow'
The following object is masked from 'package:lubridate':
duration
The following object is masked from 'package:utils':
timestamp
Attaching package: 'scales'
The following object is masked from 'package:purrr':
discard
The following object is masked from 'package:readr':
col_factor
Data Ingestion & Harmonization
Rows: 5579 Columns: 4
── Column specification ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
Delimiter: ";"
chr (4): Geocódigo, Nome do município, Sigla da UF, Bioma predominante
ℹ Use `spec()` to retrieve the full column specification for this data.
ℹ Specify the column types or set `show_col_types = FALSE` to quiet this message.
Statistical Summaries & Outlier Detection
| level | n_records | total_ha_new | total_ha_legacy | ha_diff_pct | pearson_r_def_ha | spearman_r_def_ha | mae_def_ha | rmse_def_ha | pearson_r_intensity | total_gross_emiss_new | total_gross_emiss_legacy | gross_emiss_diff_pct | pearson_r_gross_emiss | spearman_r_gross_emiss | total_net_emiss_new | total_net_emiss_legacy | net_emiss_diff_pct | pearson_r_net_emiss | spearman_r_net_emiss |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| biome | 66 | 8148210 | 8285461 | -1.656535 | 0.9972228 | 0.9967018 | 5057.20116 | 10711.7830 | 0.5828595 | 1209692883 | 1236383729 | -2.158783 | 0.9973523 | 0.9952406 | 1058473493 | 780553861 | 35.60544 | 0.9857116 | 0.9876422 |
| country | 11 | 8148210 | 8285461 | -1.656535 | 0.9949966 | 0.9818182 | 16397.57184 | 19553.5250 | 0.8333683 | 1209692883 | 1236383729 | -2.158783 | 0.9976885 | 0.9727273 | 1058473493 | 780553861 | 35.60544 | 0.9955737 | 0.9636364 |
| municipality | 61270 | 8148210 | 8285461 | -1.656535 | 0.9915232 | 0.9542717 | 8.53944 | 116.8526 | 0.3363587 | 1209692883 | 1236383729 | -2.158783 | 0.9876614 | 0.9523298 | 1058473493 | 780553861 | 35.60544 | 0.9732006 | 0.9362775 |
| state | 297 | 8148210 | 8285461 | -1.656535 | 0.9962545 | 0.9970471 | 1308.14205 | 5625.1569 | NaN | 1209692883 | 1236383729 | -2.158783 | 0.9938497 | 0.9962818 | 1058473493 | 780553861 | 35.60544 | 0.9828536 | 0.9931134 |
QA Statistical Summary by Level of Total Soy Deforestation, Gross & Net Emissions
| YEAR | n_records | total_ha_new | total_ha_legacy | ha_diff_pct | pearson_r_def_ha | total_gross_emiss_new | total_gross_emiss_legacy | gross_emiss_diff_pct | pearson_r_gross_emiss | total_net_emiss_new | total_net_emiss_legacy | net_emiss_diff_pct | pearson_r_net_emiss |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 | 5570 | 474039.3 | 466956.0 | 1.5169261 | 0.9981936 | 61209454 | 61993706 | -1.2650515 | 0.9990232 | 52536759 | 37766921 | 39.10787 | 0.9826653 |
| 2015 | 5570 | 701153.4 | 687934.9 | 1.9214735 | 0.9977887 | 95570730 | 95660777 | -0.0941317 | 0.9982390 | 82745459 | 58892287 | 40.50305 | 0.9830934 |
| 2016 | 5570 | 581025.8 | 587952.1 | -1.1780271 | 0.9980833 | 80031590 | 81661393 | -1.9958063 | 0.9987778 | 69398164 | 50848347 | 36.48067 | 0.9790400 |
| 2017 | 5570 | 886167.3 | 893996.5 | -0.8757527 | 0.9985188 | 127541983 | 130613393 | -2.3515271 | 0.9987135 | 111290592 | 81291976 | 36.90231 | 0.9804314 |
| 2018 | 5570 | 791910.5 | 803109.7 | -1.3944792 | 0.9987081 | 116648628 | 119573722 | -2.4462679 | 0.9991988 | 102094497 | 74695788 | 36.68039 | 0.9833212 |
| 2019 | 5570 | 746709.4 | 767526.4 | -2.7122246 | 0.9978006 | 110461606 | 113980035 | -3.0868817 | 0.9985365 | 96676280 | 72053151 | 34.17356 | 0.9821933 |
| 2020 | 5570 | 570702.0 | 599000.9 | -4.7243569 | 0.9956317 | 85003167 | 88298482 | -3.7320185 | 0.9944273 | 74353547 | 56431317 | 31.75937 | 0.9850333 |
| 2021 | 5570 | 801386.5 | 838821.5 | -4.4628010 | 0.9977377 | 121481795 | 127375577 | -4.6270898 | 0.9978412 | 106493175 | 81997268 | 29.87405 | 0.9842048 |
| 2022 | 5570 | 834106.5 | 861552.2 | -3.1856109 | 0.9968879 | 129295872 | 133286147 | -2.9937655 | 0.9972328 | 113664715 | 84834006 | 33.98485 | 0.9838024 |
| 2023 | 5570 | 944922.8 | 963784.1 | -1.9569947 | 0.9835769 | 154636229 | 157180265 | -1.6185469 | 0.9776249 | 136799054 | 101475288 | 34.81021 | 0.9671373 |
| 2024 | 5570 | 816086.0 | 814827.1 | 0.1545082 | 0.9658272 | 127811828 | 126760232 | 0.8295951 | 0.9481672 | 112421251 | 80267510 | 40.05823 | 0.9357898 |
QA Statistical Summary by Year (Total Soy Deforestation, Gross & Net Emissions)
| TRASE_ID | BIOME | YEAR | new_total_def_ha | leg_def_ha | abs_diff_ha | rel_diff_pct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BR-1400100 | AMAZONIA | 2024 | 16840.281 | 2519.173 | 14321.108 | 568.48448 |
| BR-1400100 | AMAZONIA | 2023 | 17948.633 | 7351.431 | 10597.202 | 144.15156 |
| BR-1400050 | AMAZONIA | 2024 | 12533.554 | 2533.216 | 10000.338 | 394.76844 |
| BR-1400159 | AMAZONIA | 2024 | 11687.608 | 1889.453 | 9798.155 | 518.57084 |
| BR-1400050 | AMAZONIA | 2023 | 11245.050 | 4412.313 | 6832.738 | 154.85615 |
| BR-1400159 | AMAZONIA | 2023 | 9966.577 | 4350.830 | 5615.747 | 129.07301 |
| BR-4318309 | PAMPA | 2023 | 16789.237 | 20030.610 | 3241.373 | -16.18210 |
| BR-1400100 | AMAZONIA | 2022 | 10134.910 | 7163.723 | 2971.187 | 41.47546 |
| BR-4306601 | PAMPA | 2022 | 13771.218 | 15798.960 | 2027.742 | -12.83465 |
| BR-4306601 | PAMPA | 2023 | 13719.616 | 15687.987 | 1968.371 | -12.54699 |
Top 10 Municipal Total Soy Deforestation Discrepancies (ha)
| TRASE_ID | BIOME | YEAR | new_gross_emiss | leg_gross_emiss | abs_diff_gross | rel_diff_pct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BR-1400100 | AMAZONIA | 2024 | 3749424 | 621753.6 | 3127670.6 | 503.04024 |
| BR-1400100 | AMAZONIA | 2023 | 4223235 | 1886194.2 | 2337041.2 | 123.90247 |
| BR-1400050 | AMAZONIA | 2024 | 2453394 | 576623.8 | 1876769.9 | 325.47559 |
| BR-1400050 | AMAZONIA | 2023 | 2464652 | 1137505.5 | 1327147.0 | 116.67170 |
| BR-1400159 | AMAZONIA | 2024 | 1543931 | 258416.3 | 1285514.3 | 497.45862 |
| BR-1400159 | AMAZONIA | 2023 | 1391829 | 643311.2 | 748518.1 | 116.35396 |
| BR-1400100 | AMAZONIA | 2022 | 2355373 | 1825872.2 | 529500.3 | 28.99986 |
| BR-1400100 | AMAZONIA | 2020 | 1700664 | 1265710.7 | 434953.1 | 34.36434 |
| BR-1400050 | AMAZONIA | 2020 | 1607444 | 1191162.7 | 416281.6 | 34.94750 |
| BR-4306908 | PAMPA | 2021 | 1735996 | 2133056.7 | 397060.4 | -18.61462 |
Top 10 Municipal Soy Gross CO2 Emissions Discrepancies (tCO2)
| TRASE_ID | BIOME | YEAR | new_net_emiss | leg_net_emiss | abs_diff_net | rel_diff_pct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BR-1400100 | AMAZONIA | 2024 | 3375761 | 468709.1 | 2907052 | 620.22512 |
| BR-1400100 | AMAZONIA | 2023 | 3824247 | 1435459.2 | 2388788 | 166.41277 |
| BR-1400050 | AMAZONIA | 2024 | 2175319 | 423155.0 | 1752164 | 414.07131 |
| BR-2911105 | CERRADO | 2024 | 4083493 | 2391635.4 | 1691858 | 70.74062 |
| BR-2911105 | CERRADO | 2023 | 3596049 | 2059438.6 | 1536611 | 74.61309 |
| BR-2201150 | CERRADO | 2017 | 4053387 | 2537524.9 | 1515863 | 59.73784 |
| BR-2101400 | CERRADO | 2024 | 3337654 | 1847990.5 | 1489663 | 80.60989 |
| BR-2911105 | CERRADO | 2017 | 3548738 | 2153619.0 | 1395119 | 64.78022 |
| BR-1400050 | AMAZONIA | 2023 | 2214448 | 857551.5 | 1356897 | 158.22917 |
| BR-2101400 | CERRADO | 2023 | 2858833 | 1519610.3 | 1339223 | 88.12936 |
Top 10 Municipal Soy Net CO2 Emissions Discrepancies (tCO2)
Diagnostic Visualizations: Total Soy Deforestation Area
Diagnostic Visualizations: Soy Deforestation Intensity (Area per Ton)
Warning: Removed 139 rows containing missing values or values outside the scale range
(`geom_point()`).
Warning: Removed 77 rows containing missing values or values outside the scale range
(`geom_point()`).
Diagnostic Visualizations: Gross Emissions
Diagnostic Visualizations: Net Emissions
Internal Validation: Forest vs. Non-Forest Breakdown (New Pipeline)
